To get their ideal retreat in the Hamptons, Frank Selvaggi and Monthly bill Shea didn’t just renovate 1 residence — they overhauled two. But that wasn’t the first approach.

In 2015, the few acquired a compact cottage in Amagansett, N.Y., for about $1 million, on a road nestled amid sand dunes extending to the ocean. The home was tiny — less than 600 square ft — but they figured they did not want pretty significantly house. And even if they experienced wished to broaden, regional developing restrictions manufactured it virtually impossible.

The composition, on the other hand, was in desperate want of function, so they hired Kyle O’Donnell, the founder of the New York-primarily based company Gramercy Layout, to rebuild it inside of the initial footprint.

“There was no insulation. There was hardly a foundation. The rafters were being undersized for the roof,” Mr. O’Donnell stated. “It was just a summer season cottage, held up by not much. Every little thing experienced to be replaced.”

Mr. O’Donnell accomplished programs for the rebuild, but just as building was about to begin, the few, now both 62, began possessing second feelings. Mr. Shea, a freelance resourceful director, prepared to stop by the home only periodically. But Mr. Selvaggi, a founding companion at Altman, Greenfield & Selvaggi, a Manhattan accounting and enterprise management firm with celebrity shoppers like Anne Hathaway and Timothée Chalamet, commenced dreaming about dwelling in the Hamptons nearly whole-time in the summertime.

“I’m rather substantially parked out there for as extensive as I potentially can be,” Mr. Selvaggi mentioned, introducing that his husband is not pretty as eager on investing limitless times on the sand. “He’s not as a lot of a seaside man as I am.”

Nonetheless, he worried they could truly feel cramped in the small cottage with their dogs, Sherlock and Dodger. So it seemed like a stroke of luck when he struck up an opportune conversation with a neighbor at a road association meeting.

“We were just chatting, and I stated, ‘Oh, I enjoy the avenue so considerably. It would be great if a little something greater arrived up,’” Mr. Selvaggi reported. “He mentioned, ‘It’s as well bad you just can’t get the dwelling subsequent to me. The proprietor is by no means there.’”

Intrigued, Mr. Selvaggi tracked down the home’s owner, obtained in touch and uncovered that the operator was receptive to marketing. Soon after some again and forth, Mr. Selvaggi and Mr. Shea struck a deal to invest in the 1,150-sq.-foot dwelling for about $1.9 million in November 2016.

Their second home, it turned out, desired just as substantially operate as the 1st, as it experienced received only insignificant updates more than the decades. But the strategy of starting off two design jobs simultaneously was challenging, so as construction proceeded on the initial household, Mr. Selvaggi and Mr. Shea moved into the more substantial a person devoid of modifying a thing.

By early 2018, the first residence was total. Alternatively than going in, the couple bought it to Anthony Bonsignore, Mr. Selvaggi’s company lover, for $1.7 million, which Mr. Selvaggi mentioned permitted the few to split even.

Then they invested another summer time in their bigger, unrenovated cottage immediately after the developing permit was delayed, and eventually commenced their next renovation in September 2019.

A great deal like the initial project, this 1 associated in essence rebuilding the dwelling from scratch in just the unique footprint. But by including dormers on the second ground, Mr. O’Donnell was equipped to enhance the home’s sizing to practically 1,350 sq. feet, generating space for three moderately sized bedrooms and two entire loos.

The layout incorporates a new floor-flooring terrace behind the household with a modest pool and out of doors shower, a pair of terraces off the major suite on the next ground, and a rooftop terrace overlooking the dunes.

The exterior of the dwelling was beforehand brown-stained board-and-batten, but Mr. O’Donnell clad the new composition in cedar shingles and outlined the home windows in Farrow & Ball’s Stone Blue, Mr. Selvaggi’s favored coloration.

Inside, “the tactic was to make it as vibrant as achievable, and as entertaining as achievable,” Mr. O’Donnell claimed, including that he required to make the rooms experience deeply at ease employing resources that could face up to damp and sandy ft.

Most of the flooring is bleached, vast-plank white oak. In the living place, he lined the ceiling with V-groove paneling and included a paneled element to the walls, which he outlined in Stone Blue. “It’s variety of a nod to a ship captain’s house, or a thing you could see in more mature residences out there,” Mr. O’Donnell explained.

In the kitchen, which he relocated to develop place for additional home windows, he set up teak cabinets reminiscent of kinds that may be uncovered on a boat and added a countertop, backsplash and window trim in White Fantasy marble.

Upstairs, the key bed room has doorways that open up to terraces on two sides: a person for sitting and chill out the other, equipped with an out of doors shower, for physical exercise. The exercise terrace also connects to the principal bathroom, which is completed in azure hexagonal tile and white marble.

Development was accomplished in June 2020, so Mr. Selvaggi and Mr. Shea did not pass up a one summer season at the seashore. Including the furnishings and inside finishes, Mr. Selvaggi approximated that the project charge about $2 million.

Now, following dwelling by means of so lots of many years of building, they have no intention of going wherever else. “It’s great out in this article,” said Mr. Selvaggi, who can walk to the seaside in fewer than a minute and enjoys catching up with neighbors more than cocktails in the night.

It’s possible very best of all, their new residence has just the proper amount of area to easily accommodate the pair, their canines and guests, with out demanding far too considerably upkeep, he explained: “It’s the best size for a seashore dwelling.”

For weekly e mail updates on household authentic estate news, indicator up listed here. Follow us on Twitter: @nytrealestate.


Resource connection